Mother Nature's Violent and Poisonous Underworld or: Stick a Cork in it!
(first published in Mineral News)
by Alfredo Petrov, December 2005
When miserable winter weather arrives, the footloose New York mineral collector
sets off for warmer climes, and this December (2005) I went again to southern Japan:
Kagoshima prefecture, the first area to rebel against the Shogun and his samurai
in the 1860s and thus turn Japan from feudalism into the modern country it is today.
Want to see what "modern" means? Your first chance is in the public restrooms in
Kagoshima airport: doors that close properly (Hello, La Guardia? Kennedy?),
electrically warmed toilet seats, and robotic gizmos that eliminate the need for
toilet paper (Goodness gracious, don't expect more details in a mineral article!)
Well, the "warmer climes" part cheated me this year. As I write these lines in
Kagoshima airport, waiting for my flight home, I can see snow falling outside on
the palm trees and tea plantations - a rather unexpected sight, but then this
trip has been filled with incongruous sights.
Kagoshima city (reachable via direct flights from Tokyo, Seoul, Shanghai or Okinawa)
is worth a geologic study visit in itself, as a city that has learned to live in
the shadow of Japan's largest active volcano, the almost continuously active
Sakurajima. Ash falls on downtown whenever the wind blows from the east, and
ashfall predictions are as much a part of the daily TV weather reports as smog
predictions are in Los Angeles. A 400 pound volcanic bomb came crashing through
the roof of a resort hotel a few years ago. [Reminder: if carrying a small one
of these home in your hand luggage, call it something else when you go through
airport security screening.] Rules for the school districts closest to the volcano
insist that all children wear hardhats walking to and from school - They look like
cute little construction worker dolls. Kagoshima also has a wonderful aquarium,
the only one in the world where you can see live tube worms - yes, those mysterious
creatures that live on stinky hydrogen sulphide gas at black smokers. [Note:
"Black smokers" here refers to neither the ethnicity nor the lung color of people
puffing on cigarettes, but rather the seafloor sulfide chimneys that spew out
hot black water laden with metal sulfides, the origin of some important mineral
deposits and perhaps of life itself.] There happens to be one at the unusually
shallow depth of 300 feet in Kagoshima Bay, whence the tube worms. I went for a
hike in Sakurajima's foothills, still within Kagoshima city limits, to see some
very rough and still fresh-looking lava flows that obliterated several villages
in the early- and mid-20th century.
Japanese school girls wearing hard-hats
|
Live tube worms in Kagoshima city aquarium
|
Fumarole depositing sulphur
|
However, my main destination was not Kagoshima city but the little island of
Iwojima, four hours by ship to the south. Iwojima means "sulfur island" in
japanese and Japan has several Iwojimas. This one is sometimes known as
Satsuma-Iwojima, after the samurai-era name for the Kagoshima region, to
distinguish it from the others (such as the infamous Iwojima of WWII, which
lies south of Tokyo). The day I was supposed to leave Kagoshima, the boat was
cancelled because of stormy weather and 13-foot waves, but no time was wasted
because a kind local collector took me to the type locality of osumilite, on
the Osumi peninsula near Kagoshima, and I was able to find several nice crystals
in spite of the cold wind and rain. The next day, waves had diminished to 8 feet,
still windy, with intermittent rain, and we shipped out. (Barf buckets provided
for the weak of stomach.) About half the passengers were local islanders going home,
and half were government employees travelling for such purposes as school
maintenance, water supply inspection, to fix the post office's computer... I was
the only foreigner on board.
|
Debris dam below Iwodake; acid steam rising in distance
|
Fumarole depositing sulphur
|
The first thing one notices as the ship approaches this little 4.5 square mile
island, population 135 and declining, is a smell of sulfur in the wind. Then the
frighteningly steep and jagged slopes of the 2,300-foot high Iwodake
("sulfur peak") volcano loom up out of the grey drizzle, dropping straight down
into the ocean, with no beach. Rounding the volcano, the landscape to the west
gets relatively more gentle and a little bay with a harbor appears, the harbor
filled with red-brown water the color of old blood, slowly oozing out into the
transparent blue waters of the surrounding sea. Our ship steams into the harbor
entrance, churning up the red and blue water boundary like a giant paint mixer.
(More on this red water later.) As I was getting off the ship, three people asked
me whether I had come to study African drumming and dancing! Or was I the new
drumming and dance teacher perhaps? Turns out Asia's only school for such African
arts is in this unlikely setting, and this seems to be the island's second main
industry, after catering to rich sports fishermen. (To round out the economy,
islanders also export a few beef cattle, cooked bamboo shoots, and camellia flowers
for cosmetic products.)
Ferry leaving Iwojima port.
|
Ferry entering Iwojima port
|
|
After dropping off my luggage at a B&B, I went hiking to scout out trails to
potential collecting sites. During the next hour I ran into large wild peacocks
several times. A now defunct resort hotel had brought a few which have bred
themselves wild over the island. In fact, peacocks have become a pest, and are
one of the reasons, along with water scarcity and sulfurous acid vapors, that
Iwojima has few vegetable gardens compared to other southern islands. Ah well,
if one must have pests, they may as well be beautiful.....But I had better start
talking about geology and minerals, before anyone forwards this manuscript to
Travel & Leisure.
|
Peacock wandering the Village
|
Iwojima constitutes a small segment, about 2.5 miles long, of the northwest
rim of Kikai caldera, a giant explosion crater which is mostly under the ocean now.
Kikai blew up 6,300 years ago, around the time human civilization was just
getting started (the world's first stone temples were going up in Malta; the
pyramids of Egypt weren't even on the drawing boards yet), and the shattered
debris of Kikai's suicide spread north and east in thick clouds that left ash
beds over much of Japan and Korea. We can assume that large numbers of the Jomon
people who then inhabited Japan and Korea came to an abrupt and choking demise.
A vertical cliff curving across the middle of Iwojima is all that is left of the
original caldera wall. Iwodake, the smoking volcano that dominates Iwojima's
landscape lies inside the caldera wall, and so must be younger than 6,300 years
old (actually much younger).
Iwodake is an ecologically instructive volcano. There are fumaroles and
solfataras inside the crater and on the outer slopes, pumping out into the
atmosphere several hundred tons a day of acrid SO2 gas (future acid rain!),
and smaller quantities of even nastier gases like HCl, H2S and HF, plus 1 to
10 tons per year of each of a long list of metal vapors, including Fe, Sn, Mo,
Zn, and poisonous heavy metals like Pb, Hg and Tl too. This is an eye-opener for
those blissful souls who believe Nature is benign and only human activities
pollute. (What are the EPA and OSHA doing about this? Perhaps a great big cork
might help?)
Remnant of Kikai caldera wall cutting across the Iwojima landscape.
|
Remnants of Kikai caldera wall.
|
Some of the fumaroles inside the crater are unusually hot - 600 to 900 degrees
C - and have been putting out high-temperature heavy-metal-laden acid gases for
at least 800 years. The rocks around active vents are red hot. Microcrystals of
molybdenum, lead and thallium minerals are also being deposited - very
educational for economic geologists, who more and more are recognizing that
some valuable metal deposits were transported and concentrated by Nature in
the gas phase rather than by liquid water (hydrothermal processes). Published
reports on the minerals of these high-temperature fumaroles are what had first
gotten me interested in this island: molybdenite, wulfenite (first recorded
locality in the world for wulfenite as a fumarolic mineral), anglesite, ilsemannite,
challacolloite, and two new but still undescribed thallium sulfides (Tl-Pb-sulfide
and Tl-Bi-sulfide).
Higashi hot springs at low tide.
|
Higashi hotsprings at high tide.
|
The crater of Iwodake was the remarkable venue for two periods of mining. The
first activity, for sulfur, began around 1542 when the Portuguese introduced
firearms to Kagoshima and Lord Shimazu needed sulfur for making gunpowder. Sulfur
mining for more modern industrial purposes reached a peak in the 1950s, with
production ranging from a couple hundred to several thousand tons per month.
Old photographs show workers carrying pickaxes, hiking single file up the trail
to the crater. Fumarolic sulfur was dug both inside the crater and on the southern
external flanks of Iwodake, and was sent to the coast by a cable that ran down
the south slope of the mountain.
Distant view of Iwodake volcano with fumaroles.
|
An unusual form of native sulfur here are the sulfur "trees" that grow over
some low-temperature fumaroles - twisted branching chimneys that grow to over a
meter high before the hollow sulfur pipes break off and the process repeats itself.
I found native sulfur also as elliptical alluvial pebbles on sand in some of the
gullies draining Iwodake. Their low density ensures they "float" on top of sand banks,
rather than sinking to the bottom like gold nuggets.
|
|
A second phase of mining started in the 1970s, this time not for sulfur but
for silica in the form of keiseki, the japanese name for an unusual "chemically
metamorphosed" rock type composed almost entirely of cristobalite, tridymite and
opal (97% SiO2), as snow-white masses formed when very acid fumaroles leached all
the Al, Fe, K, Na, Ca, Mg, etc. out of the rhyolite around the summit of Iwodake.
|
Eruption shelter, Sakurajima volcano.
|
A modern mining company took over the high peaks, built a paved road up to the
crater rim, hired local men to drive bulldozers, and erected a 2.5 kilometer cable
to carry silica rock down the southwestern slopes to the port; no more impoverished
miners with pickaxes climbing up steep footpaths. Production peaked at well over
40,000 tons per year. The keiseki was used for ceramics, for making "water glass"
(sodium silicate gel), and for "white carbon" (whatever that is).
Mining finally came to an end in 1996, not because of lack of keiseki, but
because of the availability of cheaper imported silica and because the emissions
of acid gases reached unbearable levels. A local man who used to operate a bulldozer
in the crater told me that the fumarole gases increased so much that his skin
would itch, clothes and shoes would turn brittle and fall apart in a week, tooth
enamel got rough and pitted in a few days, and something would happen to ones
hair and beard (my japanese language skills weren't good enough to understand
exactly what happens to hair and beards, but it sounded horrible). The mining
company's 2-floor office building is now the African drum and dance school.
One might ask what happens to all the many thousands of tons of K, Al, Fe,
etc., leached out of the rhyolite; where does it go? The answer is: Hot springs.
There are at least six on Iwojima, five among the rocks of its jagged coast, and
one under the seawater in the port. Higashi hotsprings emits crystal-clear water
and has been dammed up with some strategically placed stones and cement, forming
pools of different temperatures where one can elect to either boil oneself alive
or have a nice relaxing hot soak under the stars, depending on which pool one steps
into. But learn from my painful experience and do not rub your eyes after wetting
your fingers in the pool; the water is rich in highly astringent potassium alum
and other acid aluminium sulfates (and a trace of arsenic). (So that's where all
the K and Al in the leached-out feldspars went; I had been wondering... and one
must sometimes suffer pain for science.) This astringent water is alleged to be
good for the skin, getting rid of wrinkles and making you look younger.
Standard Iwojima picnic lunch wrapped in leaves
|
Akayu hotsprings nearby (Akayu means "hot red water") and Nagahama hotsprings
under the port emit very iron-rich water, with lesser amounts of manganese. The
water in the port contains 191 ppm ferrous iron - an extraordinarily high
concentration for seawater!
|
Microbes metabolize the soluble ferrous salts,
producing ferric hydroxides (which is what gives the seawater its red color)
and precipitating what the microbiologists call "biomats", which consist of
the mineral species goethite, ferrihydrite, buserite and birnessite, precipitated
around microbial filaments. The biomats cement sand grains together, forming
"bioterraces" which under ideal conditions can grow remarkably rapidly - up to
one meter thick in three months! (Looking back at Precambrian banded iron ores,
one wonders whether perhaps these accumulated much faster than we thought.)
Well, I regret to say I never made it close enough to the high-temperature
fumaroles to get any wulfenite or thallium sulfides; too worried about damaging
my lungs and camera, or perhaps just choking to death. Anyone less chicken than
me who is planning to try this should take a respirator with full face mask, like
the old gas masks from WW 1, and asbestos-soled boots. The abundant keiseki
doesn't have any vugs with crystals, but I did find a few pieces with tabular
yellow inclusions of native sulfur pseudomorphs after feldspar crystals, and many
impure keiseki boulders encrusted with bright red botryoidal hyalite opal,
presumably colored by ferric iron oxide (hematite) probably formed by hydrolysis
of ferric chloride-rich fumarole gas.
|
The prize finds of my field collecting on
Iwojima was a lump of highly altered vuggy rhyolite, rich with beautiful
microcrystals of transparent blue roedderite (much nicer color, if I may say so
without offending the Germans, than the roedderite from the Eifel hills). Also
one boulder with dark green acicular hypersthene and some excellent tridymite
trillings up to 6mm - relatively large for tridymite.
|
Shrine gate, looking towards Iwodake.
|
References:
Africano, F., et al. (2002) Earth Planets Space, 54, 275-286.
Hamasaki, S. (2002) Earth Planets Space, 54, 217-229.
Kazue, T. (2000) Clays and Clay Minerals, 48, 511-520.
|